Denotational Semantics of Gradual Typing using Synthetic Guarded Domain Theory
Gradually typed programming languages, which allow for soundly mixing static and dynamically typed programming styles, present a strong challenge for metatheorists. Even the simplest sound gradually typed languages feature at least recursion and errors, with realistic languages featuring furthermore runtime allocation of memory locations and dynamic type tags. Further, the desired metatheoretic properties of gradually typed languages have become increasingly sophisticated: validity of type-based equational reasoning as well as the relational property known as graduality. Many recent works have tackled verifying these properties, but the resulting mathematical developments are highly repetitive and tedious, with few reusable theorems persisting across different developments.
In this work, we present a new denotational semantics for gradual typing developed using guarded domain theory. Guarded domain theory combines the generality of step-indexed logical relations for modeling advanced programming features with the modularity and reusability of denotational semantics. We demonstrate the feasibility of this approach with a model of a simple gradually typed lambda calculus and prove the validity of beta-eta equality and the graduality theorem for the denotational model. This model should provide the basis for a reusable mathematical theory of gradually typed program semantics. Finally, we have mechanized most of the core theorems of our development in Guarded Cubical Agda, a recent extension of Agda with support for the guarded recursive constructions we use.